What are some examples of conflict of interest?

A conflict of interest arises when a person or entity has competing interests or loyalties that could potentially compromise their ability to act impartially or prioritize the best interests of another party. In the context of a health benefits plan fiduciary, a conflict of interest occurs when a committee member's personal, financial, or professional interests could influence their decision-making or create the perception of bias.

Here are some examples of conflicts of interest that may arise for fiduciary committee members in relation to a health benefits plan:

1. Financial Interest: A committee member may have a financial stake in a company or service provider associated with the health benefits plan. For example, they may own stock in a pharmaceutical company that provides medications covered by the plan, potentially influencing their decisions regarding drug formulary selection or pricing negotiations.
2. Family or Personal Relationships: A committee member may have a close relationship with an individual or organization involved in the health benefits plan. For instance, they may have a family member employed by a healthcare provider that contracts with the plan, raising concerns about impartiality when making decisions related to network provider selection or claim reimbursements.
3. Employment Outside the Organization: Committee members may hold positions or have financial ties with other entities that are in direct competition or have conflicting interests with the health benefits plan. This could include serving on the board of a healthcare company that competes with a plan vendor or having a consulting arrangement that could influence decisions on plan design or vendor selection.
4. Gifts or Personal Benefits: Committee members may receive gifts, favors, or personal benefits from vendors or service providers associated with the health benefits plan. These can create a conflict of interest if the acceptance of such gifts could influence decision-making or compromise objectivity.
5. Dual Roles: Committee members who serve in multiple roles within the organization, such as being an executive and a fiduciary committee member, may face conflicts of interest. They may need to balance their fiduciary duties with their responsibilities to the organization, potentially creating conflicts between organizational goals and the best interests of the plan participants.
6. Financial Advisor Relationships: If a committee member has a financial advisor or consulting relationship with a service provider or investment firm involved in the health benefits plan, it could create a conflict of interest when making decisions related to plan investments or the selection of investment managers.

It's important for fiduciary committee members to be aware of potential conflicts of interest and disclose them to the committee. By doing so, the committee can assess and manage these conflicts appropriately, ensuring that decisions are made impartially and in the best interests of the health benefits plan participants and beneficiaries.

For support in managing your fiduciary responsibilities, visit Fiduciary In A Box.

© 2023 Fiduciary In A Box, Inc. All rights reserved.