How should a plan fiduciary determine if a vendor's compensation is reasonable?

Determining the reasonableness of a vendor's compensation is a critical fiduciary responsibility that involves a thorough evaluation of the services provided and the fees charged. Here's how a plan fiduciary can assess the reasonableness of a vendor's compensation:

1. Request Detailed Disclosures: Request comprehensive compensation disclosures from the vendor. This should include a breakdown of all fees, charges, and any revenue-sharing arrangements. Understand the scope of services provided and how the vendor's compensation aligns with those services.
2. Benchmarking: Compare the vendor's fees with industry benchmarks to assess whether they fall within a reasonable range. Various industry sources provide fee benchmarks for different types of services. Comparing fees with market standards can help identify any outliers.
3. Consider the Scope of Services: Evaluate the comprehensiveness of the services the vendor offers. A vendor charging higher fees might provide additional value in terms of expertise, technology, customer support, or other services that contribute to the overall benefit.
4. Review Independent Reports: If available, review independent reports or studies that analyze the reasonableness of compensation in the industry. These reports can provide additional insights into what is considered reasonable for specific services.
5. Fee Transparency: Ensure the vendor provides transparent and clear explanations for all fees. Avoid vendors that are reluctant to provide detailed fee information or those with complex fee structures that are difficult to understand.
6. Evaluate Value: Consider the value delivered by the vendor's services. Are they providing tangible benefits that justify the compensation? For instance, an investment advisor's performance and returns might justify higher fees.
7. Assess Industry Practices: Understand common practices in the industry for similar services. If a vendor's fees are significantly higher or lower than what is typical, investigate further to ensure there's a valid reason.
8. Conflicts of Interest: Evaluate whether the vendor's compensation structure creates conflicts of interest that might compromise their ability to act in the best interests of the health plan and its participants.
9. Alternative Vendor Options: Obtain quotes or proposals from multiple vendors offering similar services. This can help you compare fees and services to determine if the chosen vendor's compensation is reasonable.
10. Document the Process: Document the steps taken to evaluate the vendor's compensation. This documentation demonstrates that you have fulfilled your fiduciary duty to prudently assess the vendor's fees.
11. Seek Expert Advice: If you're unsure about the reasonableness of a vendor's compensation, consider seeking advice from industry experts, consultants, or legal professionals who specialize in employee benefits.

Ultimately, determining the reasonableness of a vendor's compensation requires a thorough and systematic assessment of various factors. Fiduciaries should prioritize transparency, thorough analysis, and alignment with the best interests of the health plan and its participants.

For support in managing your fiduciary responsibilities, visit Fiduciary In A Box.

© 2023 Fiduciary In A Box, Inc. All rights reserved.