How Can Bundling or Unbundling Providers Reduce Administrative Costs?

When managing a retirement plan, employers must carefully consider how to balance cost efficiency with the quality of service. The choice between bundling or unbundling plan providers plays a significant role in determining administrative costs, with each approach offering distinct advantages.

Bundling Providers: Streamlined Efficiency

Bundling plan services involves selecting a single provider to handle multiple aspects of the retirement plan, such as recordkeeping, investment management, and compliance. This approach can significantly reduce administrative costs through streamlined operations. Since one provider manages the majority of plan services, there’s less need for coordination across multiple vendors, which saves time and reduces the complexity of managing the plan. Additionally, bundling often comes with the benefit of economies of scale. Providers that offer bundled services can often deliver these services at a lower combined cost than if they were provided separately by different vendors. These providers may also offer package deals or discounts that reduce overall fees, making the administration of the plan more cost-effective [1].

Furthermore, with a bundled provider, employers typically have a single point of contact, which simplifies communication and problem-solving. This reduced administrative burden translates into lower internal costs, as HR departments or plan administrators spend less time managing multiple relationships and resolving issues across different service providers [2]. In essence, the bundling approach offers a more cohesive experience that can lead to reduced administrative overhead.

Unbundling Providers: Competitive Cost Savings

On the other hand, unbundling providers allows employers to choose the best and most cost-effective option for each service required by the retirement plan. By shopping around for individual services—such as selecting one vendor for recordkeeping and another for investment management—employers can often secure more competitive rates. This approach can lead to significant cost savings, especially if employers are diligent in negotiating fees and ensuring that they are not paying for unnecessary services included in a bundled package.

Unbundling also provides greater transparency into the costs associated with each component of the retirement plan. When services are unbundled, employers can see exactly what they are paying for each service, making it easier to identify and eliminate inefficiencies or redundant expenses. For example, if an employer finds that a particular service is overpriced, they can switch to a more cost-effective provider without disrupting other parts of the plan. This level of control can be particularly advantageous for larger organizations with the resources to manage multiple vendor relationships efficiently [3].

Balancing Cost and Complexity

While both bundling and unbundling offer pathways to reducing administrative costs, the right choice depends on the specific needs and capabilities of the employer. Bundling may offer the most straightforward way to lower costs through simplified administration and package deals, while unbundling provides flexibility and the potential for targeted savings by carefully selecting and managing individual providers. Employers should weigh these options carefully, considering their own administrative capacity, the complexity of the plan, and their ability to negotiate and manage provider relationships effectively.

References:

 [1] Waggoner, J. (2022). The Benefits of Bundling Your 401(k) Plan Services. U.S. News & World Report. Retrieved from https://www.usnews.com/benefits-of-bundling-401k-plan 

 [2] Fiduciary News. (2021). How Bundling 401(k) Services Can Cut Costs. Retrieved from https://www.fiduciarynews.com/bundling-401k-services-can-cut-costs 

 [3] Green, M. (2023). Maximizing Savings: The Case for Unbundled 401(k) Plans. Investopedia. Retrieved from https://www.investopedia.com/maximizing-savings-unbundled-401k-plans 

For support in managing your fiduciary responsibilities, visit www.fiduciaryinabox.com.

© 2024 Fiduciary In A Box, Inc. All rights reserved.